| Team name | Location | League | Level | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lima Chiefs | Lima, Ohio | Ohio-Indiana League | professional | defunct |
| Lima Phillies | Lima, Ohio | Ohio-Indiana League | professional | defunct |
| Lima Terriers | Lima, Ohio | Ohio-Indiana League | professional | defunct |
| Marion Cubs | Marion, Ohio | Ohio-Indiana League | professional | defunct |
| Marion Red Sox | Marion, Ohio | Ohio-Indiana League | professional | defunct |
| Muncie Reds | Muncie, Indiana | Ohio-Indiana League | professional | defunct |
| Newark Yankees | Newark, Ohio | Ohio-Indiana League | professional | defunct |
| Portsmouth A's | Portsmouth, Ohio | Ohio-Indiana League | professional | defunct |
| Richmond Roses | Richmond, Indiana | Ohio-Indiana League | professional | defunct |
| Richmond Tigers | Richmond, Indiana | Ohio-Indiana League | professional | defunct |
| Springfield Giants | Springfield, Ohio | Ohio-Indiana League | professional | defunct |
| Zanesville Dodgers | Zanesville, Ohio | Ohio-Indiana League | professional | defunct |
| Zanesville Indians | Zanesville, Ohio | Ohio-Indiana League | professional | defunct |