| Team name | Location | League | Level | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Chambersburg | Chambersburg, Pennsylvania | Keystone Association | professional | defunct |
| Chester Blue Stockings | Chester, Pennsylvania | Keystone Association | professional | defunct |
| Lancaster Red Stockings | Lancaster, Pennsylvania | Keystone Association | professional | defunct |
| Littlestown Brown Stockings | Littlestown, Pennsylvania | Keystone Association | professional | defunct |
| York White Roses | York, Pennsylvania | Keystone Association | professional | defunct |