| Team name | Location | League | Level | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tiffin Mud Hens | Tiffin, Ohio | Ohio State League | professional | defunct |
| Toledo Mud Hens | Toledo, Ohio | Triple-A East | professional | active |
| Toledo Mud Hens | Toledo, Ohio | Western Association | professional | defunct |
| Toledo Mud Hens | Toledo, Ohio | Southern Michigan Association | professional | defunct |
| Toledo Mud Hens | Toledo, Ohio | American Association | professional | defunct |
| Toledo Mud Hens | Toledo, Ohio | Inter-State League | professional | defunct |
| Toledo Mud Hens | Toledo, Ohio | International League | professional | defunct |